November 18, 2008

If it is not a job for the market it is still less a job for the government!

Michael Skapinker in “Every fool knows it is a job for the government” November 18 seems quite willing to let the pendulum on financial regulations to go back completely based on a “Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me”.

Skapinker would do well remembering that no matter how much talk of de-regulation there is we got here primarily because the financial regulators in Basel concocted what the thought was a magical potion capable to eliminate the risks in banking for ever, the minimum capital requirements for banks based on vaguely defined risks of default, and then empowered the credit agencies to serve as the Masters of the Risk in the world. Without that, we would be where we are.

And please, do not argue that the same thing happened with the dotcom bust. There investors were pursuing profits in an always risky stock market while this crisis happened because investors followed what was supposed to be AAA least risky securities, and which by the way pokes fun at the whole concept of allocating risks with those better able to manage it.

And so, before we start swinging, let us make sure where the pendulum really is. Perhaps it is because I have never minded government regulations, when clearly needed, that I find it much easier not sending the government where it is not needed. Long live the radical middle!